Improve
Writing Ability
Although we
ourselves have enthusiastically advocated writing across the
curriculum and related reforms, we have found no convincing
research base for these programs.
The above comment
reflects the current status of a nation-wide educational program
known as Writing Across the Curriculum (WAC).
Writing Across the
Curriculum refers to focusing on writing in courses besides
English composition such as biology, history, literature,
mathematics, and chemistry. WAC has several strong features, but
in some ways it has been oversold. Also, it tends to shift the
responsibility and accountability for teaching writing away from
where they belong, the English class.
WAC – which has the
goals of improving writing ability, reasoning skill, and course
mastery in academic subjects – emerged from the same tradition
and teachers that produced the process approach partly to
rectify the disappointing performance of the process approach in
English classes.
English teachers find
the question "What should I write about?" a perennial problem
with the process approach. So process theorists suggest that
students use the approach for writing about the subject matter
of other courses. Writing about the material in a history or
chemistry class solves the problem of what to write about.
Also, process theorists
are finding the process approach less effective than expected
for strengthening students' writing and analytical skills in
English classes. They maintain that the problem is that students
are not writing enough in other classes.
A primary rationale for
WAC is the claim that writing is a way of discovering new
knowledge, ideas, and insights. The major evidence for the claim
comes from reports by some professional writers that they are
often surprised by what they write, that characters in their
novels or plays develop independent personalities and control
what the typewriter prints.
In WAC students are told
they should write without expecting class credit or teacher
comments but solely for their improved understanding and course
mastery; however, teachers find them generally unconvinced. Most
students take an assignment seriously only if it is to be handed
in and contributes in some way to their grade, claiming all
courses place heavy demands on their time. Perhaps if WAC
activities showed more dramatic benefits, students would find
them more intrinsically motivating. As it stands, if teachers
don't bother periodically collecting, evaluating, and crediting
WAC assignments, students don't bother doing them.
Taking notes while reading textbooks is
among the oldest yet best ways of using writing to improve
learning. It is also, ironically, the one writing activity WAC
has neglected to encourage because of its stress on having
students write freely, express impressions, and use the process
approach to create their own meaning.
Relationship Between Thinking and
Language
Teaching Writing:
Inquiry Approach
Writing
Relationship Sentences
Teaching Usage and Functional
Grammar
Run-on Sentences
Verb Problems: Tense And
Form
Combining Sentences Having the Same
Subject or Predicate
Combining Sentences With Prepositional Phrases |